Based on the first 40 minutes of the film and Chapters 1–11 of the book, does the visual version of Chris’s journey make his choices seem more justified or more reckless than the text does? Explain how the medium (film vs writing) shapes your perspective.

 I think that the visual version of Chris's journey fails to make his choices seem more justified compared to the book. With the book, I am able to further understand Chris's motivations for his choices because of Krakauer's analysis of his decisions. The medium shapes my perspective because the author goes deeper into Chris's mindset, so I am able to understand why he might make the reckless choices that he did. Overall. the film allowed me to fully picture the situations that Chris put himself in to, yet failed to justify his choices as much as the book did.

In class, we started to watch the film and answered comparison questions.

I learned about how different medias allow for different understandings of a story or character.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

As we think about our upcoming Vocabulary Monday, tell me what is your favorite word RIGHT NOW? Why is it your faovorite word and how often do you use it?

 My favorite word right now is scoop. I like this word because of its simplicity and the way it rolls off my tongue. It also makes me think of scoops of ice cream or a skill in volleyball. I don't use it often, but when I do, it is enjoyable.  Today in class, we worked on our slide projects.  I learned how to connect my childhood experiences to Frost's themes. 
Read more

Write about a time when you realized you needed to look out for yourself in a silly or harmless situation—maybe dodging a pop quiz, escaping a group chat argument, or remembering at the last second to submit an assignment. How did choosing wisely make your life easier?

 One time, I had to write a DBQ the next period, but I had forgotten to do the prep work, so I was completely unprepared. I decided to have my mom call me out right before the class, so I wouldn't have to go and write the DBQ. I took the DBQ the next Thursday, and I did really well on it because I had studied and was prepared. This made my life easier because I had less stress going into the test, and I was able to take my time with studying, rather than writing it without any background knowledge and failing it.  In class, we finished our short story and answered questions on it. I learned how to answer the questions using evidence from the story and what I read. 
Read more

The last scene forces readers to reinterpret Emily’s entire life. Write about a moment when new information changed your perception of a person or situation. How did that “plot twist” reshape your understanding, the same way Faulkner’s ending reshapes the story?

 One time when new information changed my perception of a person was when I found out that my friend was depressed and had an eating disorder. This changed my perception of her because she seemed like the happiest and healthiest person ever, and she showed no signs of struggling.  This reshaped my understanding of everyone because I found out that you never know what is actually going on in someone's mind or at their home. It made me think deeper about all of my loved ones and to make sure I would check up on them. In class, we took a quiz on the story and then watched a movie of it. I learned how to work with my group to figure out the right answers. 
Read more